I'll play, without cheating. I would guess My Punching Bag. I also think My Punching Bag will be the one who solves my favorite song riddle on Okkervil River's Stage Names album, just so I will like him.
A better guess would be Stamper, but I think My Punching Bag has more posts. It's probably close.
Okay, I'm going to claim victory, and name the next trivia question, which I've mentioned twice tonight already.
My favorite song on Okkervil River's Stage Names. No multiple guesses, because there are only nine songs. You have to guess the song, and state your reasoning. If you are wrong, you are not allowed to guess again (I'm looking at you JWW).