|
Author | Topic: Top 15 (ignoring possible conflicts) (Read 803 times) |
know ID yuh Abominable Snowman
     member is offline
![[avatar] [avatar]](http://www.gunthernet.com/images/thumbs/7.jpg)
Joined: Apr 2008 Posts: 3,327 Location: Portland
|  | Top 15 (ignoring possible conflicts) « Thread Started on Feb 22, 2009, 9:39pm » | |
Rather than rank the board's lists based on total points, I am ranking it based on the number of lists an act appears on, using total points as a tie breaker. This is to give a more accurate representation of who the board wants to see, rather than a couple people throwing off the rankings because they really like a particular band. For example, Gaslight Anthem and Blitzen Trapper both have the same amount of points, 25, but six people want to see Gaslight Anthem, while only three want to see Blitzen Trapper. Just because there are three people who really like Blitzen Trapper does not make them more can't miss, especially with such a small sample size (17 responses so far).
On the list below, I have included every act with at least three votes. The total points are based on 15 points for a first place vote, 14 for second, on down to 1 point for a 15th place vote. If you submit(ted) a list of 12 for example, 12 points for first, 11 for second, etc. I deleted Peter Bjorn and John from the rankings, rather than poop up each band below them up a point.
Interesting to note that two of the headliners are 14th and 15th. Of all acts receiving a vote, Ben Harper would be last, since he has one point. Not one vote for Monday's subhealiner either.
1. Fleet Foxes 133 (16) 2. Explosions in the Sky 150 (14) 3. Animal Collective 140 4. TV On the Radio 122 (13) 5. Of Montreal 81 (11) 6. Bon Iver 97 (10) 7. NIN 105 (9) 8. Decembrists 91 9. Yeah Yeah Yeahs 72 (8) 10. Grizzly Bear 35 11. Devotchka 56 (7) 12. Avett Brothers 51 13. Girl Talk 47 14. Jane's Addiction 58 (6) 15. Kings of Leon 53 16. Gogol Bordello 48 17. Passion Pit 47 18. M83 36 19. Gaslight Anthem 25 20. Monotonix 36 (5) 21. Walkmen 28 22. Dodos 26 23. Doves 25 24. Calexico 24 25. M. Ward 23 (4) 26. King Khan & the Shrines 14 27. Shearwater 29 (3) 28. Blitzen Trapper 25 29. Black Moth Super Rainbow 23 30. Sun Kill Moon 31. Chromeo 15
My List: 1. Animal Collective 2. Monotonix 3. NIN 4. Explosions in the Sky 5. Fleet Foxes 6. Yeah Yeah Yeahs 7. Jane's Addiction 8. M83 9. Bon Iver 10. Avett Brothers 11. Passion Pit 12. Girl Talk 13. King Khan & the Shrines 14. Gogol Bordello 15. M. Ward
|
|
|
lolocaustsquirrel Guest
|  | Re: Top 15 (ignoring possible conflicts) « Reply #1 on Feb 22, 2009, 9:48pm » | |
I like this idea, it'll be interesting to see what people say.
For me, the list goes roughly like this:
1. Animal Collective 2. Explosions In The Sky 3. Shearwater 4. The Dodos 5. TV on the Radio 6. Of Montreal 7. Yeah Yeah Yeahs 8. Grizzly Bear 9. Gaslight Anthem 10. Viva Voce 11. M83 12. Fleet Foxes 13. School of Seven Bells 14. Horse Feathers 15. Peter Bjorn and John
...and about 15 more.
| |
|
g0ldfinga Grunting Yowie
  member is offline
![[avatar] [avatar]](http://i307.photobucket.com/albums/nn313/devils-haircut/wayne-coyne-1.jpg)
Joined: Mar 2008 Gender: Male  Posts: 248
|  | Re: Top 15 (ignoring possible conflicts) « Reply #2 on Feb 22, 2009, 9:56pm » | |
1. The Decemberists 2. Hockey (yea they are probably billed the lowest out of everyone but they rock, check out the Mind Chaos on LP) 3. Passion Pit 4. Monotonix 5. Animal Collective 6. Girl Talk 7. EITS 8. NIN 9. JA 10. Fleet Foxes 11. Avett Bros 12. Doves 13. James Pants 14. TVOTR 15. Gaslight Anthem
check out http://www.artistticket.com/link/?s=hockey
Hockey is touring with Passion Pit in the UK
| |
|
vitaminr Human
 member is offline
Joined: Jan 2009 Gender: Male  Posts: 14
|  | Re: Top 15 (ignoring possible conflicts) « Reply #3 on Feb 23, 2009, 12:31am » | |
1.Explosions In The Sky 2.The Wrens 3.Fleet Foxes 4.Animal Collective 5.The Avett Brothers 6.Blitzen Trapper 7.Bon Iver 8.Blind Pilot 9.M83 10.Decemberists 11.Dent May & His Magnificent Ukelele 12.Monotonix 13.Gogol Bordello 14.Of Montreal 15.Doves
| |
|
Whoopsie Goldberg Howling Windigo
   member is offline
Joined: Mar 2008 Gender: Male  Posts: 254 Location: Idaho
|  | Re: Top 15 (ignoring possible conflicts) « Reply #4 on Feb 23, 2009, 2:23am » | |
1. DEADMAU5, c'mon guys.... this is going to be crazy. 2. Peter Bjorn & John..I don't know... theres just something about these guys 3. N.I.N...their last tour possibly? Its high energy shit. 4. Fleet foxes. soo good last year 5.Explosions 6.Animal Colective 7. yeah yeah yeahs. girltalk tvotr grillzy bear dodos doves bleh
| |
|
jobosrock Grunting Yowie
  member is offline
Joined: Jun 2008 Gender: Male  Posts: 147 Location: BC, Canada
|  | Re: Top 15 (ignoring possible conflicts) « Reply #5 on Feb 23, 2009, 3:34am » | |
1. Explosions in the Sky 2. Nine Inch Nails 3. Gogol Bordello 4. TV on the Radio 5. Animal Collective 6. of Montreal 7. Devotchka 8. Black Moth Super Rainbow 9. Grizzly Bear 10. Passion Pit 11. Chromeo 12. Doves 13. Avett Brothers 14. Peter, Bjorn, and John 15.Fleet Foxes
| |
|
ramblindude Human
 member is offline
Joined: Feb 2009 Gender: Male  Posts: 8
|  | Re: Top 15 (ignoring possible conflicts) « Reply #6 on Feb 23, 2009, 10:19am » | |
1. The Decemberists 2. Of Montreal 3. Bon Iver 4. TV on the Radio 5. Passion Pit 6. Fleet Foxes 7. Yeah Yeah Yeahs 8. Animal Collective 9. Devotchka 10. Natalie Portman's Shaved Head (Crazy good live!)  11. M83 12. Explosions in the Sky 13. The Dodos 14. Calexico 15. Ra Ra Riot
| |
|
msbands Grunting Yowie
  member is offline
![[avatar] [avatar]](http://images.proboards.com/avatars/boyandmower.gif)
Bring Kay Kay & his mighty underground.
![[aim] [aim]](http://images.proboards.com/aim.gif)
![[homepage] [homepage]](http://images.proboards.com/buttons/www_sm.gif) Joined: Feb 2009 Gender: Male  Posts: 134 Location: Bothell, Washington
|  | Re: Top 15 (ignoring possible conflicts) « Reply #7 on Feb 23, 2009, 11:25am » | |
1. Gogol Bordello 2. The Submarines 3. Bon Iver 4. TV on the Radio 5. Passion Pit 6. Fleet Foxes 7. Kings of Leon 8. Animal Collective 9. Devotchka 10. Natalie Portman's Shaved Head 11. M83 12. Explosions in the Sky 13. PB&J 14. Grizzly Bear 15. TBA (Mogwai, Shins or Smoosh)
|
|
|
interstateeight Human
 member is offline
![[avatar] [avatar]](http://i472.photobucket.com/albums/rr88/coug1313/sasquatchchristmasfinal.gif)
Joined: Jan 2009 Gender: Male  Posts: 1 Location: San Francisco
|  | Re: Top 15 (ignoring possible conflicts) « Reply #8 on Feb 23, 2009, 2:51pm » | |
The very fact that you felt the need to say "no one will call you an asshole" and try to speak for us has led me to do this: You're all assholes.
That said:
1.) TV on the Radio 2.) Explosions in the Sky 3.) The Gaslight Anthem 4.) The Decemberists 5.) DeVotchKa 6.) Of Montreal 7.) Girl Talk 8.) Fleet Foxes 9.) Bon Iver 10.) M. Ward
That's it so far.
|
|
|
bradberad12 North American Bigfoot
    member is offline
![[avatar] [avatar]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/fMKCPW_HO8E/default.jpg)
Joined: Feb 2009 Gender: Male  Posts: 508 Location: Vancouver
|  | Re: Top 15 (ignoring possible conflicts) « Reply #9 on Feb 23, 2009, 3:16pm » | |
Interstate, we are not all assholes. We are actually humans. Yes, even you.
Here's my List:
1) The Doves 2) The Explosions in the Sky 3) The Kings of Leon 4) The M. Ward 5) The Bon Iver 6) The Avett Brothers 7) The Of Montreal 8) The Blitzen Trapper 9) The Fleet Foxes 10) The Gogol Bordello 11) The Walkmen 12) The Loch Lomond 13) The Decemberists 14) The Sun Kil Moon 15) The Dodos
There, ccoult, that's better. Thanks for nitpicking
| |
|
ccoult Grunting Yowie
  member is offline
Joined: Feb 2008 Gender: Male  Posts: 187 Location: Victoria, B.C.
|  | Re: Top 15 (ignoring possible conflicts) « Reply #10 on Feb 23, 2009, 3:28pm » | |
Sorry to nitpick brad, but there is no "the" in "The Doves", thought you might like to know since they are your #1 band!
1. Bon Iver 2. Explosions In The Sky 3. Fleet Foxes 4. The Walkmen 5. Kings of Leon 6. Animal Collective 7. M83 8. The Dodos 9. Girl Talk 10. YYYs 11. PBJ (hope they are still there!) 12. Demitri Martin 13. TV on the Radio 14. King Khan & the Shrines 15. Chromeo
| |
|
scough Man-Eating Higabon
     member is offline
![[avatar] [avatar]](http://fi.somethingawful.com/customtitles/title-ruffz.jpg)
Joined: Jan 2009 Gender: Male  Posts: 962 Location: WA
|  | Re: Top 15 (ignoring possible conflicts) « Reply #11 on Feb 23, 2009, 3:39pm » | |
1. Jane's Addiction 2. Yeah Yeah Yeahs 3. NIN 4. Fleet Foxes 5. Sun Kil Moon 6. Silversun Pickups 7. The Decemberists 8. Kings of Leon 9. TV on the Radio 10. Explosions In The Sky 11. Animal Collective 12. The Gaslight Anthem 13. Monotonix 14. of Montreal 15. Grizzly Bear
| |
|
interstateeight Human
 member is offline
![[avatar] [avatar]](http://i472.photobucket.com/albums/rr88/coug1313/sasquatchchristmasfinal.gif)
Joined: Jan 2009 Gender: Male  Posts: 1 Location: San Francisco
|  | Re: Top 15 (ignoring possible conflicts) « Reply #12 on Feb 23, 2009, 4:47pm » | |
Feb 23, 2009, 3:16pm, bradberad12 wrote:Here's my List:
1) The Doves 2) The Explosions in the Sky 3) The Kings of Leon 4) The M. Ward 5) The Bon Iver 6) The Avett Brothers 7) The Of Montreal 8) The Blitzen Trapper 9) The Fleet Foxes 10) The Gogol Bordello 11) The Walkmen 12) The Loch Lomond 13) The Decemberists 14) The Sun Kil Moon 15) The Dodos
There, ccoult, that's better. Thanks for nitpicking |
|
|
|
|
sqatchinup Human
 member is offline
Joined: Feb 2009 Gender: Male  Posts: 7
|  | Re: Top 15 (ignoring possible conflicts) « Reply #13 on Feb 24, 2009, 2:14am » | |
1) Animal Collective 2) Devotchka 3) NIN 4) Explosions in the Sky 5) TV on the Radio 6) Fleet Foxes 7) Chromeo 8) Kings of Leon 9) Calexico 10) Shearwater 11) Jane's Addiction 12) The Walkmen 13) Viva Voce 14) of Montreal 15) Ben Harper
| |
|
ccoult Grunting Yowie
  member is offline
Joined: Feb 2008 Gender: Male  Posts: 187 Location: Victoria, B.C.
|  | Re: Top 15 (ignoring possible conflicts) « Reply #14 on Feb 24, 2009, 6:11pm » | |
Feb 23, 2009, 3:16pm, bradberad12 wrote:Interstate, we are not all assholes. We are actually humans. Yes, even you.
Here's my List:
1) The Doves 2) The Explosions in the Sky 3) The Kings of Leon 4) The M. Ward 5) The Bon Iver 6) The Avett Brothers 7) The Of Montreal 8) The Blitzen Trapper 9) The Fleet Foxes 10) The Gogol Bordello 11) The Walkmen 12) The Loch Lomond 13) The Decemberists 14) The Sun Kil Moon 15) The Dodos
There, ccoult, that's better. Thanks for nitpicking |
|

| |
|
|